I've never had a chance to swap just the turntable before, while keeping everything else the same. It's pretty mind-blowing how much of a difference there is in the sound of the two.
Take this for what it's worth Baggers, but I thought the Luxman I heard (509, IIRC) with the P3s was almost too much of a good thing. Sprinkling sugar on top of honey, or something like that.