I already ordered one from Tangent. thanks though.
I was using a grinder to shorten the shaft (I'm OCD for the length being perfect, andI've done this dozens of times before) and the grinding wheel grabbed the point that I had grinded, and spun the shaft. I didn't know wnyhting happened, until I was done, and went to turn the pot. Oops.
What went wrong, was I had forgotten to shorten the length before hand, and had already soldered the pots on the board. I couldn't hold it at the same angles I usually use, and I think that's what did me in. Oh well, could be worse.