I just wanted to provide an update on two scotches that have drastically changed my opinion of themselves in polar opposite ways as I delved deeper into the bottle.
Port Charlotte 10yo Heavily Peated
This Islay whisky has quite a bit of floral and fruity peat to it. It's smooth and complex, beyond its years, very much like the Bruichladdich offerings. But as I get deeper into the bottle, I find myself grabbing for other Islay whiskies instead. It lacks the character and the boldness of the other great heavily peated Islay offerings like Ardbeg, Laphroaig, and Lagavulin. It doesn't have the campfire or iodine notes that distinguish each of the other distilleries. I certainly still think it's a good dram but I would buy it more often if it was near the $50 mark instead of $70. I understand that they are somewhat of a craft distillery and their lower volumes and more time intensive methods have intrinsic value and are worth the addition cost. I very respect what Bruichladdich are doing and they are still one of my favorite distilleries but I really think that their subtle, rich, complex whiskies are better unpeated. On the first couple of tastings, I would have given it somewhere in the high 80s, but now I give it an 82.
Yoichi 15yo
This bottle started out quite unremarkable. It had very little flavor and a strong alcohol punch even though it's bottled at 45%. As my palate settled down and the flavors opened up after the bottle had been opened, things became more and more interesting. It is quite Japanese in character; Very subtle but extremely complex. It is comparable to many 20 or 25 yo. It's obvious that care had been taken to both engineer the flavor and produce the whisky. It has strong oak notes with floral and nutty flavors. It might be worth noting that I made the purchase in Japan before it was available in the US purely based on perceived scarcity. After opening, I was disappointed with the investment. But if you ask me again now, I'd say it's just about worth the $120. I would liken it to a good Springbank. Initially, I would have given it no more than low 80s but now I would give it a solid 90. It is the best scotch that I have open right now; On par with the Uigeadail.
Summary: Yoichi 15 - great, Port Charlotte 10 - not so great.