I'm getting a couple of bottles of Eclipse via trade......I've never had one before so I'm asking for yall's opinion. Which out of this list should I get: 
 
2011: 4 roses, heaven hill, ec18, buffalo trace, brandy, grand cru, 
2010: heaven hill 
 
I'm almost certain on getting an EC18 but I'm not sure which to get for my 2nd bottle. I'm tempted to get the 2010 Heaven Hill/Rittenhouse rye but I've read on multiple reviews that 2010 was not a good year for that variant. 
 
Thoughts?