I got to see both the Pelagos and the Black Bay today. In all honesty, I think the Pelagos build is up there with my Rolex Sea Dweller and I would definitely own one of those. The Black Bay was nice but did not really impress me nearly as much and it appears to plummet in value so quickly after purchase. I have seen several less than year old going for around $2k.
I did actually really like a Chopard Monaco Historique that I looked at today. All in house from the movement to the really overbuilt Ti case.