Jump to content

Beyer T50P review


Wmcmanus

Recommended Posts

Well I had no interest in them before, but now I kinda almost want to hear them out of morbid curiosity :)

It's not worth it, I did the same thing - they are as terrible as people say. That and it's impossible to get a good fit if you have a small head.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 79
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

:rofl::rock:

:rofl::rock: Maybe you wouldn't recall, but once you called me a jerk at HF for saying that some guy there, raving madly about the DT-48, then selling them, was a disgusting thing to do hahahaha. I think you purchased those DT-48, now I know your opinion :P:D

Ehh, don't remember that. Sorry if I called you a jerk and you're not, in reality, a jerk. I must have been looking for like company.

As for the DT-48's, Matt (NightWoundsTime) can confirm that I broke my pair before I had listened to them for 10 seconds. They're not as indestructible as people claim they are! I tried them on at a meet (somewhere, can't remember where, probably Tampa) and they squeezed my head so badly that I figured, "Hmmm, maybe if I stretch them out a bit." But they seemed to bounce right back no matter what I did, until I stretched them with a wee bit too much force and snapped the indestructible headband in two. So I never did listen to them.

I've still got them, and was hoping that maybe one day I'd run across a headband solution that works. Beyer doesn't have any of the originals as best I can tell from the limited amount of research I did, but even if they did, the clamping force would be way too tight for my comfort. In any case, I eventually found another pair at another meet and gave them a quick listen. They're really nowhere near as bad as the T50P.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Never mind Wayne. At that moment I felt bad but now it's long gone. I like to think I'm not a jerk, but as everything in life, it's debatable ;D

I've never listened to music using the DT-48, just test tones and sweeps. Those phones are a reference for psychoacoustic studies in medicine. I happened to work at a place that had them about 18 years ago (more or less). I found them very uncomfortable and didn't feel tempted to try them with the Discman I had by those days. When I read about people using them for music... :palm: To each one his/her own I guess :)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I dunno. We have a pair of the T50ps in the lab I'm in at the moment and they sound pretty good to me. Definitely an odd balance off the top, with a relatively low-impact bass, but there's a fair bit of detail and they present a decent soundstage for their size. The only other phones used there are the AT-M50s and AKG 240s and some cracked Equations so difficult to draw meaningful conclusions but I'd say the Beyers are good, if idiosyncratic performers, capable of musical involvement and, depending on what's upstream, an extended but slightly uptilted treble. Comfort seems fine for the category, despite the headband padding resembling a fridge seal. Don't know if I'd own 'em, but don't think they suck.

best,

k

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 1 month later...
  • 4 months later...

I've never listened to music using the DT-48, just test tones and sweeps. Those phones are a reference for psychoacoustic studies in medicine. I happened to work at a place that had them about 18 years ago (more or less). I found them very uncomfortable and didn't feel tempted to try them with the Discman I had by those days. When I read about people using them for music... :palm: To each one his/her own I guess :)

Things have changed. The 3 sets of DT-48's I had in the 70's were very rolled off in the highs and lows, and not just uncomfortable - they pressed on certain ear parts and were painful. Enter the new DT-48E (and only the 'E' version). It looks exactly the same. The thicker ear cushions, and extra padding inside next to the driver screen, eliminated the comfort issue. Unless you're claustrophobic.

But the sound. You wouldn't expect something that sounded like the old DT-48 to sound like a Sennheiser HD-800 today. And they don't. But they're very nearly as good. The bass is still shy, but not rolled off like the old 'phones. You don't get the impact of the really deep stuff, but it sounds really good otherwise. The highs are there, and clear. And the mids are spectacular. You would probably never hear another 'phone like the DT-48E. Very highly recommended.

One little caveat - the new DT-48 still collects sweat in the earcups - same as the old version.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

To play devils advocate, the ears continue to grow and hearing change throughout your lifetime. 40 years might change some things.

It's a valid thought, but in this case I did my homework. The sealed pads on the new 48E (the previous 48's weren't sealed - you could rotate them 360 degrees) make the difference in the bass. Just put the 48E on and get a good seal, play some music with bass, then yawn really wide, which breaks the seal, and listen to the bass disappear. The much better highs I can't account for yet. Although I can tell you this - when I yawn to kill the bass, the highs also sound much more like the old DT-48's. Currently my hearing goes flat to 10 khz and drops maybe 3 db at 12 khz, so with the DT-48 and my Sennheiser 800's I can make a pretty good judgement about the sound. When I had the Soundcraftsmen equalizer I could equalize headphones to within 1 db of the Koss ESP9's. I could do that now. Piece 'o' cake.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I talked with Todd about this briefly last night (the TTVJ Todd). He said that he sent his pair of T50P back to Beyer and they apparently confirmed with him that there was something "wrong" with them (whatever that means) and have since sent him a replacement pair. He said that the new pair arrived the other day but he hasn't listened to them yet. I asked him if he was afraid to listen to them, and his response was "No comment". Too bad he doesn't still have the original pair on hand to make comparisons.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Tastes change too. I know I like very different things than I did only 5 years ago.

My tastes haven't changed since 1974. I knew what live music sounded like then, and thanks in no small part to J. Gordon Holt, I've been pursuing that ever since. Some headphones wear out. The Beyer DT-48 does not. Hearing changes for some people, but mine hasn't changed at all below 12 khz. I find that the Sennheiser HD-800 is a good reference point from which to judge other 'phones, and the DT-48 provides balance in that judgement as well.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.