The saga of messing with my 2nd Carbon build continues. Since the circuit is very close to the Grounded Grid, I'd like to give it a try. Being hesitant to spend big bucks on a nice quad EL34, I have been on the lookouts for a cheaper substitute.
The curve of a pentode looks a lot like that of a SiC FET. I need a pentode with the following properties:
The plate curve should have low kinks or no kinks at the low Va range. The lower the 'knee' the better.
Low Ig2. Ig2 should be much smaller than Ia (20mA), ideally 1mA or less under the operational Va range such that Ig2 doesn't interfere with cathode drive/ cathode degeneration.
The amount of negative bias needed to get 20mA at 400V should be reasonably easy to handle.
High rated Va(max) and Pa(max) for using a higher supply voltage and/or idle current in the future. That means I may need to look into transmitting tubes.
And the candidate is... (drum roll please) the FU-50/GU-50!
The linearity looks pretty good at around Ia=20mA, from Va=100V all the way to 1kV!
The bias voltage is between -20V and -25V, right around what Carbon has.
The Ig2 is really low and changes very little from Va=100V to 1kV.
More importantly, the FU-50/GU-50 are relatively inexpensive and plentiful. A lot of them were made in the USSR and China during the cold war era. I read somewhere that those were designed for the comm gear used in the tanks and had very little success in commercial applications. I paid less than $3 a pop from Ukraine about 15 year ago. The going price for a NOS tube should be close to a SiC FET today. Well, any tube not designed for audio can be cheap these days. However, that wouldn't stop people from chasing after the Telefunken LS50 and the east-Germany SRS-552s, I guess 😉
Adapting those to the Carbon is surprisingly easy. I removed the SiC FETs and the 20k bias resistor, replaced the two 175k resistors with a 100V and a 130V 3W zener diode for G2 supply. The Ig2 is really small and the two tubes can share one set of the zener diodes. They drop 230V from GND and set Vg2 right at 150V, with about 22V left for the PZTA42 and the offset pot.
The heaters are powered by a 12.6V filament trans with one side tied to B-. I could have tied the CT but there was very little hum to worry about.
Guess what, the GU-50s work right out of the box. I didn't even need to adjust the balance and offset!
The measured performance is pretty decent:
Although the distortion is low, the FFT does show some higher order 'pentode nastiness'. I guess the reasons being
The pentode is not super linear to begin with.
The transconductance of the GU50 is about 1/10th of the SiC FET. The PZT42 has to work much harder and the global NFB is less effective.
Something else worth looking into
I'm not yet able to seriously listen to the sound, because I couldn't find another pair of tube sockets in my stash for the second channel 😂. If you want to know how it sounds, try it!
The GU50 with 400V PSU comfortably beats the KGST (below) on the frequency response and the output swing:
Next to try is to use the pentodes on the KGST, or should I call it KGSP then?